Beyond the Headlines: Understanding the Causes of Family Homelessness

By Valerie Kaufmann, Policy Advisor

Family homelessness in New York City is often discussed in terms of rising rents and a shortage of affordable housing. While these factors play a significant role, families experience homelessness due to a range of circumstances that can overlap and compound one another. Domestic violence, overcrowded living arrangements, and eviction can all contribute to a family’s housing instability.

Shelter-entry data provide important insight into why families seek emergency housing, while also representing only one part of the broader experience of family homelessness. Families who temporarily stay with friends or relatives, move frequently between homes, or remain in unsafe housing may experience significant housing instability without ever entering the shelter system.

Although this discussion focuses on New York City, family homelessness is a challenge facing communities across the country. The specific circumstances may vary depending on local housing markets, economic conditions, and available support systems, but families in cities, suburbs, and rural communities alike can experience housing instability for many of the same reasons. Understanding the causes of homelessness is essential to developing effective prevention strategies to make sure every family has a safe and stable place to call home.

Domestic Violence is a Primary Cause

In fiscal year 2025, domestic violence was one of the most common causes for shelter entry, accounting for 34% of family entries into the New York City Department of Homeless Services (DHS) shelter system.i

Domestic violence can force parents and children to leave their homes suddenly to escape abuse. Survivors may lose access to housing, financial resources, and essential support when they leave an abusive relationship. Without savings, a reliable support network, or access to safe and affordable housing, finding somewhere secure to live can be extremely difficult.

Survivors of domestic violence should not have to choose between remaining in an unsafe environment and facing housing insecurity. Emergency shelter, specialized support services, and affordable long-term housing can help individuals and families find safety and establish stable living arrangements.

Overcrowding: An Overlooked Risk

Overcrowding accounted for 22% of family entries into the NYC Department of Homeless Services (DHS) shelter system in fiscal year 2025.ii For many families unable to afford housing independently, staying with relatives or friends becomes a last resort before shelter. While these arrangements may temporarily prevent shelter entry, they often involve families living in crowded, unstable and unsuitable conditions, without the security of a permanent home.

These living situations are often unsustainable. Limited space, financial disagreements, changes in household circumstances, and strained relationships can make an overcrowded household difficult to maintain. Families may have little control over how long they can stay and, when the arrangement ends, may have few immediate alternatives to entering the shelter system.

Families living with relatives or friends may also be overlooked in official U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) homelessness counts and face barriers to accessing the same resources available to families staying in shelters. This challenge is particularly significant in jurisdictions without a right to shelter, where families experiencing housing instability may have even fewer avenues for accessing emergency accommodation and support. Even in New York City, where families have a right to shelter, those living in overcrowded or temporary arrangements may remain outside the formal homeless services system and struggle to access assistance until their circumstances deteriorate. Many believe that the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act definition of homelessness used by the U.S. Department of Education to identify homeless students is more accurate as it is more inclusive of this population.

Recognizing overcrowding as a potential precursor to homelessness is therefore important for identifying and supporting families before they reach crisis point. Although overcrowding alone does not mean a family will necessarily enter shelter, it can provide an important indication of underlying housing insecurity and vulnerability before a family reaches the point of shelter entry. These families may benefit from rental assistance, housing navigation, and access to affordable homes before their current situation breaks down. Identifying and supporting these families earlier can help prevent a temporary arrangement from becoming a housing crisis.

Housing Affordability and Eviction

The high cost of housing remains a central factor in family homelessness. In 2024, nearly half (49%) of renters in the United States spent at least 30% of their income on rent and utilities, and 26% spent at least 50% of their income on rent and utilities.iii When rent consumes a large share of a household’s income, families have less money available for food, transportation, child care, and other necessities. Even a relatively small financial setback—such as reduced work hours, an unexpected expense, or a delay in benefits—can make it difficult to keep up with rent.

Eviction can turn this financial pressure into an immediate housing crisis. In fiscal year 2025, eviction accounted for 21% of family entries into the NYC DHS shelter system.iv However, formal eviction is only one way families lose housing. Some leave before a court process is completed, while others are asked to leave a shared household or are unable to renew an informal living arrangement.

Preventing homelessness means supporting families before a crisis becomes unavoidable. Rental assistance, access to legal services, and early intervention for households at risk of eviction can help families remain housed. Increasing the supply of genuinely affordable housing is also essential to addressing the underlying conditions that leave so many households vulnerable.

What the Data Reveal

Although shelter-entry statistics help identify common pathways into homelessness, they should not be viewed as a complete account of families’ experiences. A reported reason for entering shelter may reflect the immediate event that prompted a move rather than the longer chain of circumstances that made a family vulnerable.

For example, a family may be evicted after months of financial strain, or an overcrowded living arrangement may become untenable because the household providing temporary accommodation can no longer afford its own rent. Similarly, domestic violence may intersect with financial dependence and a lack of alternative housing.

Families who are in overcrowded conditions, move between temporary homes, or stay in unsafe environments may also be absent from shelter-entry statistics. Recognizing these limitations is important for understanding both the scale of housing instability and the range of support families need.

Moving Forward: What Can We Do to Address Family Homelessness?

Addressing family homelessness requires more than responding when a family enters shelter. It also means recognizing the warning signs of housing instability, strengthening community support, and ensuring families can access resources before a crisis occurs. While policymakers, nonprofits, and housing providers play an important role, communities and individuals can also contribute to these efforts.

Questions to Consider:

  • What does family homelessness and housing instability look like in your community? Explore what local authority homelessness statistics and housing data reveal, alongside the lived experiences of families facing housing insecurity. Consider the challenges families experience beyond finding somewhere to live, including insecure tenancies, overcrowding, transport costs, disrupted education, access to childcare and difficulties maintaining employment.
  • What does the pathway into and out of homelessness look like for families in your community? Explore how systems such as emergency shelter, rental assistance and housing vouchers work, and the pathway to access them (perhaps through a helpline, a website, or a local community hub). Consider what barriers families may encounter, such as limited housing availability, affordability, complex application processes or a lack of ongoing support to maintain a tenancy.
  • Which local organizations (e.g. food banks, shelters, faith groups, community centers) are working to prevent family homelessness or help families transition into permanent housing? What knowledge, skills or resources can you bring to support them? For example, could you offer legal, financial, employment or educational expertise, help families navigate available services, or connect organizations with potential partners?
  • How can you engage constructively in local housing discussions? Learn about and demonstrate support for proposed affordable housing developments in your area. Respond to local housing consultations, attend community board and council hearings and engage with your local representatives.

Preventing family homelessness is a shared responsibility that requires meaningful engagement across the community. This begins with understanding the lived experiences of families facing housing instability, as well as the wider systems and barriers that influence their housing options. It also involves championing the development of affordable housing and recognizing the valuable skills, knowledge and resources that individuals, businesses and community organizations can bring to the fight against homelessness.

In doing this, community members can play an active role in developing more effective responses to family homelessness and expanding access to stable, affordable housing.

Conclusion

Family homelessness is not simply a story of individual hardship, nor an issue limited to New York City. It reflects the interaction of economic pressures, housing shortages, safety concerns, and gaps in the systems designed to support families.

By addressing domestic violence, overcrowding, unaffordable housing, and eviction together, we can move beyond responding to homelessness after it occurs. A more effective approach prioritizes prevention by focusing on root causes, expands access to affordable housing, and uses quality shelters as the safety net they are intended to be.


 i. Coalition for the Homeless. “State of the Homeless 2026.” June 2026. pp. 15. https://www.coalitionforthehomeless.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/State_ofthe_Homeless_2026.pdf. 

ii. Ibid.

iii. Airgood-Obryck, Whitney. “Six Takeaways from America’s Rental Housing 2026.” Joint Center for Housing Studies, March 12, 2026. https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/six-takeaways-americas-rental-housing-2026.

iv. Ibid.